What Is Developmental Trauma? How It Shapes Your Relationship With God -Psychology & Scripture
What is trauma, really? A Christian therapist explains developmental trauma, attachment, and why it can shape how you see God.
Episode summary
You hear the word “trauma” constantly, but what does it actually mean, and what does it have to do with your faith? In this episode, licensed marriage and family therapist Kia Gutiérrez introduces trauma as a companion to attachment theory, giving you a psychologically and Scripturally grounded way to understand your emotions.
Kia traces how trauma entered the research world through the PTSD diagnosis for war veterans, and offers her own working definition: trauma is the experience of needing help and not receiving it, or, in attachment terms, needing secure connection and being blocked from it. From there she explains developmental trauma, which can come from the chronic absence of basic needs being met during the early years, when a child’s brain is deciding whether the world is safe and whether they’re securely attached. Using examples like food scarcity in childhood, she shows why someone with a fractured foundation may find it harder to trust than someone who had secure attachment before a traumatic event.
Then Kia brings it to Scripture. If we’re created first for connection with God, then struggling to believe that God is trustworthy, safe, good, loving, or a provider may point to an insecure attachment with Him, or lived experiences of needing God when it felt like He wasn’t there. She explains why reading the Bible without room for that history can make it feel like our pain isn’t worth attention.
You’ll finish with a question to carry with you: how does reading the relationships in Scripture through the lens of developmental trauma change the story?
Kia Gutiérrez: Last week we talked about the concept of attachment theory. Attachment theory is the idea that humans are created asking, humans are designed, built, whatever language you want to use, they're asking the fundamental question: Am I connected? Am I loved? More than they're asking the question, what can I accomplish? that's a psychological concept that we use to interpret what happens when Adam and Eve eat from the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, and it results in distance immediately in the relationship between humans and God and humans and each other. today, I want to introduce another concept that. We will be using in tandem with attachment theory and scripture that is foundational to how we can read scripture to interpret our emotions in a psychologically grounded and scripturally grounded way. that is the concept of trauma. Trauma is a word that we talk about pretty often these days. But it's a relatively new concept to the psychological research world. I may get my history a little bit wrong, but the first major trauma diagnosis was PTSD and it applied specifically to war veterans. it was meant to diagnose and track specifically what happens when a person who has a healthy brain goes into a situation like war. And experiences an event that challenges all their definitions of safety and connection. They're all of their worldviews are challenged and they're left feeling incredibly unsafe, not just physically, but morally and socially. And this resulted in a diagnosis called post-traumatic stress disorder, meaning after something stressful. You have residual stress that is hard for your body to process. The research on why this stress is difficult for your body to process is that fundamentally trauma is the experience of needing help and not receiving it. Another way that you could say that in the context of attachment theory is trauma is the experience of needing to be securely attached and not receiving or having access to or being blocked from that secure attachment. since the PTSD diagnosis, they have created a A new diagnosis that is not recognized in the DSM V, which is the diagnostic manual that the United States uses. However, in Europe there is a different diagnostic manual, and this diagnosis has been recognized, and it is called Developmental Trauma. Developmental trauma is different than PTSD in the sense that developmental trauma applies to people who experience not just traditionally recognized traumatic events such as war or death or loss or violence, but it can also be the chronic absence of. Their basic needs being met. Developmental trauma takes place during your developmental years. Attachment is formed throughout your entire life. But the foundational building blocks that your brain will use to build their definition of the world moving forward, the foundations are laid from zero to three. Before a child is even verbal. Their brain is deciding whether or not the world is safe and whether or not they are securely attached. if they are securely attached, that means that there's freedom to explore, create, learn. If they are not securely attached, it means that they need to develop a system of self-protection or vigilance. And they need to be more cautious about being curious, developing, growing. Learning, making friends, because they have learned that those situations can threaten their basic survival. when you are zero to three, if you don't have someone feeding you, you don't live. If you don't have someone comforting you, you don't get comfort. If you don't have someone keeping you warm, you don't get warm. these first three years, Incredibly important. developmental trauma happens when a child learns I am not securely attached. I am not safe in my world. Maybe not a hundred percent unsafe, but I have learned that on some level. My needs are not going to be met adequately. And it happens more than one time. as the frontal lobe starts to become more active and online. It continues to ask the question Am I loved? Am I securely attached? If the answer to that question is no, I'm not safe, the brain doesn't already have a strong foundation of connection to build off of. The foundation itself is fractured. So if that child, let's say, lives in poverty, this is a classic basic form of developmental trauma where food is not regularly available to them, they are going to have a fractured sense of security in their brain. They're gonna have neuropathways that tell them there's not always enough food and the consequences of logic that follow that that can result in insecure attachment to their parents. If their parents are always gone working, or if there's fights over food, or whatever it is. Okay, very basic. If that child runs into a situation of violence when they're 11, but there was food scarcity since they've been born, they're not gonna have the same foundation that a person Who went to war with a solid foundation, they're going to have a harder time accessing hope and secure attachment offers because they already believe the world is unsafe. Whereas a person who potentially has PTSD, not developmental trauma, just PTSD, they have already learned previous to the traumatic event. That they have secure attachments, there are people who are gonna take care of them, they have autonomy and control over their life and an identity that they can work backwards towards or build off of in their new identity post this traumatic event. But a child with developmental trauma doesn't have that foundation to go back to. Okay. How does this apply to scripture? I'm going to argue that we are not created just to be attached to anyone. We are fundamentally created to be attached to God. That's the first connection that we see in scripture, is between God and Adam. And then we see human relationship introduced. But fundamentally, We are created for connection with God first and each other as well. Whenever we have an issue that we're struggling with around the character and nature of God, whether or not God is trustworthy, whether or not He's safe, whether or not He's good, whether or not He's loving, whether or not He is going to provide. If we're struggling with that concept, it's reasonable to assume we have an insecure attachment with God. We have some developmental trauma hindering our communication with God. We have some lived experiences where we feel like we needed God and he didn't show up. There was a time when we needed him, and he wasn't there. If we read scripture glossing over the fact that all of us wrestle with some sort of History of feeling separated from God. There is going to be a lot of scripture that feels like it's saying that our pain is not worth attention, that our feeling that God wasn't there should be ignored. psychologically, if developmental trauma is ignored in human relationships, it has catastrophic impacts on how healthy a person can be emotionally and relationally. Which we're going to unpack more of. For now, I want you to consider. That if we're fundamentally created for connection with God and trauma fundamentally indicates any moment where we have felt disconnected from God, how does that change the way that we read about all of the relationships in Scripture? If we started reading all those relationships in Scripture through the lens of developmental trauma, how does that change the story?