Psychology and Scripture
  • Home
  • Episodes
    Christianity 1 Religion & Spirituality 1 Mental Health 1 Season 1 3 All Episodes 8
  • Leave a Review
  • About
  • Follow
    Spotify podcast player icon Spotify
    Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music
    All Players
  • Store
  • Search
Contact
Contact
Search
Oct. 2, 2026

What is an Emotion? - Psychology & Scripture

What is an Emotion? - Psychology & Scripture
What is an Emotion? - Psychology & Scripture
Psychology and Scripture
What is an Emotion? - Psychology & Scripture
Your browser does not support the audio tag.
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Season 1
  • Show Notes
  • Transcript

I'm a therapist, and I swore off emotions at 19. Here's why I changed my mind, and what an emotion actually is.

Episode summary

What is an emotion? Christians hear very different answers. Some say emotions are spiritual forces, like angels or demons influencing you. Others say they're a weakness of the flesh that Scripture warns us not to trust.

In this episode, licensed marriage and family therapist Kia Gutiérrez shares why she swore off emotions at 19 after a painful moment leading worship, and why, as someone who still isn't a big fan of feeling them, she believes feeling our emotions is the most efficient way to get rid of the feeling and make wise choices.

You'll hear her definition of an emotion at the intersection of faith and psychology: a chemical process in your body that has hugely significant spiritual meaning. It's not an attack imposed on us from outside, and it's not something to press down and ignore. Drawing on Genesis 1 and the idea that we're made in God's image, Kia explains why she believes there's a message in every emotion that points toward a foundational truth, one that helps us make wise decisions and build healthy relationships.

She also steers between two extremes: that every negative emotion is a spiritual attack and every positive one a blessing, or that emotions are terrible and should never be felt.

Then she leaves you with one question to sit with: how does it feel to know your emotions were given to you by God, with a purpose you get to discern?

Kia Gutiérrez: Of course, the therapist thinks the solution to all your problems is to feel your emotions. Big surprise. Okay, let's talk about it. I actually don't I'm not a big fan of emotions. Truly. When I was 19, I swore them off entirely. There was this moment where I was helping lead worship at this mission space, and I was really nervous about it, really uncomfortable, and I ended up leading this prophetic song. Where it was about rest and it was really encouraging people to rest in the Lord and what He was doing in that moment. after the song, one of the leaders came up to me and said that that was a really terrible idea and that I should not have done that. and that I should never Leave people in rest again. All love to this leader because they were having a moment and I understand that in the context of hindsight, right? they were what I would call triggered by the word rest because they had a lot of things they were really stressed out and worried about. But Nineteen year old me was really, really hurt and really, really sad. it kind of lined up with a lifetime of feeling emotions and it not paying off. It's a lot of work to feel. Physically it's a lot of work. and I wasn't really sure it was worth the investment. Spiritually it's a lot of work. so when I took this step out both spiritually and physically and socially, 'cause I was doing this emotion thing publicly, and then to have very direct feedback from people that I cared about that said that was really not a good idea, I decided, yeah, emotions are dumb, I'm not gonna feel them anymore. I don't see why we need them, they have no purpose. Obviously, I'm a therapist now who specializes in feeling your emotions. But the way that I do it isn't really somatic. I I mean it is, but it isn't. So let let's talk about my approach to feeling emotions and why I think you should consider it, even if you don't like emotion. Like I don't. I still don't like emotion. But the research that I've done over the last decade, maybe close to fifteen years now, is that unfortunately feeling our emotions is the most efficient way One, to get rid of the feeling, and two, to make really good choices. Really good choices. So what is an emotion? Let's define it. as a Christian, there's a lot of confusion around what an emotion is. It could be a spiritual experience. it could lean very supernatural, it could be like angels and demons sort of situation, whatever language you use to describe some form Force, spiritual force influencing you, and that influence translates to something that feels or looks like an emotion. Another version of what emotions are in the Christian faith is that it's purely a biological response and it needs to be dominated as a weakness of the flesh. Essentially, emotions are They're a weakness. They're a built-in weakness of the body. They're chemical. They have no spiritual foundation at all. And there's a lot of scripture that suggests they can't be trusted and shouldn't be listened to. so a lot of there's a lot of teaching around not feeling your emotions at all. because we can respond to our emotions in ways that are hurtful to other people. And we're gonna talk about that later. Right now we're just talking about what is an emotion. My definition of an emotion Is a combination of both, which is going to be a repeated theme you hear in our chats together, is that I think that the intersection of faith and psychology is where we gain some real clear insight. So my definition of emotion is it's not hundred percent spiritual. It is not the enemy or an angel or anything talking to you. it is a chemical process in your body. It is. It's a chemical process in your body. However, that chemical process has hugely significant spiritual meaning. And we're gonna talk about what that meaning is. I think we need to walk in that in-between space of both and yes and yes, emotions are spiritual, but they are not an attack or something that's imposed upon us externally. It's an internal process. And our emotions are chemical. They are chemical reactions that are involuntary in our bodies. But that does not mean that they should be pressed down and ignored. I think that God created our biological bodies in his image because that's what it says in Genesis one. Let us make man in our image. he created us to feel emotions. There is a message, in my opinion, in every single emotion that leads us to a spiritual truth, a bedrock foundation truth that we can go through a process to use to make wise decisions and have healthy relationships. However, if we swing all the way over to emotions are terrible and we should never feel them, or Emotions are everything, and we should always pay attention to them. Every negative emotion is a spiritual attack, every positive emotion is a blessing. I don't I don't lean that way. let's just start with how do you feel about the fact that your emotions were given to you by God and that He has a purpose for them and that they are an involuntary chemical response in your body, that you now have the privilege as a human being created in the image of God. to unpack to discern the purpose and value of how does that how does that how's that feel

Psychology and Scripture

Is it a sin to feel angry or afraid? Pull up a chair. Psychology and Scripture is a short, friendly Christian podcast about emotions, mental health, and therapy, where real psychology meets real Scripture.I'm Kia Gutiérrez, a Christian therapist: a licensed marriage and family therapist with over fifteen years of experience, and a floundering faith walker-outer. As a therapist, I believe there is a way of feeling our emotions that leads us to the healthiest choices we can make. How we do that is the part we should unpack.Each episode is short: a nugget of Christian psychology, a look at what the Bible says, and one thing to chew on this week. Not more to do, just more awareness of who God made you to be, and the confidence to do the next right thing.Our first series follows my book Emotions as Messengers. Start at the beginning or jump in wherever your question is.This podcast is for education and encouragement and is not a substitute for therapy or professional mental health care.Looking for conversations about the American church? Check out my first podcast, The Church We Dream Of.

  • Episodes
  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • About
  • Store
  • © 2026 Psychology and Scripture
  • Podcast Website by Podpage