Psychology and Scripture
  • Home
  • Episodes
    Christianity 1 Religion & Spirituality 1 Mental Health 1 Season 1 3 All Episodes 8
  • Leave a Review
  • About
  • Follow
    Spotify podcast player icon Spotify
    Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music
    All Players
  • Store
  • Search
Contact
Contact
Search
Nov. 4, 2026

What Does Attachment Theory Say About the Fall of Man? - Psychology & Scripture

What Does Attachment Theory Say About the Fall of Man? - Psychology & Scripture
What Does Attachment Theory Say About the Fall of Man? - Psychology & Scripture
Psychology and Scripture
What Does Attachment Theory Say About the Fall of Man? - Psychology & Scripture
Your browser does not support the audio tag.
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
  • Show Notes
  • Transcript

Why did Adam and Eve hide from God? A Christian therapist reads Genesis 3 through attachment theory.

Episode summary

You've heard the story of Adam, Eve, and the fruit of the tree, but have you ever read Genesis 3 through the lens of psychology? In this episode, licensed marriage and family therapist Kia Gutiérrez retells the fall of man and asks a question: what happened to the relationships?

Kia walks through the story, including why Eve's decision to "be like God" looks reasonable from where she stood, and what happens right after: fear becomes the first emotion on the page, Adam and Eve hide from God, and they turn on each other. God's response is to go looking for them with the question "Where are you?"

Then Kia brings in attachment theory, the idea that the human brain is built less to accomplish than to connect, and that we're constantly asking, "Am I securely attached?" She frames Genesis 3 as the moment secure attachment first broke, both between humanity and God and between Adam and Eve themselves. She also explores why choosing to be our own God means trying to attach only to ourselves, and why that never works, using the example of people who survive alone in the wilderness but can't live a full life without connection.

You'll leave with a question to carry into the coming episodes: what would it mean to read the Bible as the story of God pursuing his people to restore secure attachment, and how would that change the way we experience emotion in Scripture?

Kia Gutiérrez: Bible story time. We're gonna have Bible story time. Now I know you've heard this story before because it's literally, depending on how much study you've done of the Bible, either the first or second story the Bible. We're gonna be covering a little bit of Genesis three. The whole temptation bit. The whole fall of man, right? So I'm guessing you've taken a gander. at these passages in your faith because it's pretty important, right? What we think of what happened in Genesis three is very important to our faith. Today we're going to talk about it slightly different. We're gonna talk about it through the lens of psychology, as we do here, and I'm very excited because I think it's going to teach you something about yourself, something about God, and something about why your feelings matter. So let's do this. Okay? What happens in Genesis 3? Well, there's a tree put into the middle of Paradise and on this tree there's some kind of fruit, something that looks good to eat. And this thing represents knowledge. God says, Hey Adam, that knowledge, not for you. Don't touch it. He actually says, Don't eat it. But I'm giving the Kai a paraphrase version, because you know the scripture. Okay? So Don't touch it. No touchy. Not good. then it's not good that Adam's alone. Eve is in the picture now. It's very exciting. We love Eve. We're a fan. Eve is in the garden, doing what she's supposed to be doing, called by God to tend and nurture the garden. And she sees the tree. And this snake shows up and is like, Hey, you should eat that fruit that God said you shouldn't eat. And Eve's like I dunno. That's th that's not really what I was told was a good idea. And then the snake's like, Well, is that really what he said? Because you're pretty smart. You're a pretty smart chicken, and this tree is gonna help you be even smarter. It's gonna help you be even more like God. Because you were already created in the image of God, were you not? I'm paraphrasing to make my point. in Genesis one it says, Let us make man in our image, which we already talked about. We're made in the image of God who has emotion. He also has the ability to make decisions. So the snake's like, yo, if you eat this, you'll be even more like God. It's like if all the Avenger movies, it's like you could be a superhuman, you could be a super god. You could you could be God himself. You could do what God does if you eat this fruit. And Eve goes, Well that seems like a good idea. Don't laugh at her, okay? I can hear you laughing a little bit because you know that this story does play out well. But don't judge Eve too quickly when she decides, hey, being God, me being God, good idea. I like it. I think I can do that. I will eat the yummy fruit. Notice that the fruit is yummy. It's not a gross fruit. It's not a bad thing that she has to eat. It's a good thing. Good thing. Eat good thing be like God. Equal good. Why wouldn't it be? Why wouldn't it be? Well we know why it's not because we read the rest of the story. But Eve has not read the rest of the story. All she's doing is disobeying God just a little bit. Just a little. Just a little. Okay? Okay? what happens? She eats the fruit then Adam eats the fruit with her. immediately there's distance in their relationship. They start blaming each other. immediately they're afraid. Fear is the very first emotion here. Fear. They've eaten the fruit and they're afraid. God is walking through the garden as he always does. They love walking with God in the garden. It's one of their favorite things. now he's walking in the garden, and They have exposed themselves, I would say, to how much they don't know. now they're afraid of God. so They hide. They hide from God. They create distance. They create relational distance. God seeks them out to restore and close the gap of that distance. he says, Where are you? He's calling out to them, Where are you? they say, We're hiding, you know, they come out. God said, What happened? And what? Do Adam and Eve do with their new skill of knowledge? They've just been given God-like advanced skills beyond what God Himself felt was appropriate to give them. And they said, That's a good idea. I'll do that. Why would it be bad to have more of a good thing? What do they do with more of a good thing? Do they do more good? No. They immediately turn on each other. the unity that was in their relationship is instantly broken. Not by God, not even by the snake. They choose it. Now that they have knowledge, they choose to blame each other. Had they ever blamed each other before? It's not documented. It could have happened, but they are choosing to blame each other in this moment. Here's the psychological concept I want to bring in to frame this. It's called attachment theory. Attachment theory says that people are fundamentally created to ask the question, not what can I do, but am I loved? That's a can of worms anyways, we can unpack that. for now, attachment theory suggests that the primary function of the human brain is not to accomplish but to connect. To connect. To stay joined with another. In the early years of our life, zero to three, our brain goes through a growth process of learning to define the world at a really, really basic fundamental level. attachment theory says that our brain is asking over and over again: Am I securely attached? Is there someone who's going to show up for me no matter what? Before If the brain learns that it's not securely attached, it will adapt and create anxious attachment, disorganized attachment. Or withdrawn attachments. All three of those are Are built off the foundation that their relationships are not secure and safe, that they fundamentally can't trust people on some level. They can't trust the people in their lives. How does this apply to Genesis 3? Before Eve and Adam ate from the tree, they were securely attached to God. They had a purpose, they had a mission, They had wisdom in the context of what was appropriate for the relationship and connection that they had with the ultimate deity, God. When they ate from the tree and They redefined those relationships immediately and introduced a lack of security in the relationship. For the first time, they withdrew from God. They withdrew. They created distance. If a brain is created for connection and eating the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, regardless of unpacking the significance of that, if the result is distance between us and God, it means whatever that was goes against attachment theories foundation for our ultimate purpose in life, which is to be connected and securely attached relationships. Not only was the relationship between God and Adam and Eve no longer secure, the relationship between Adam and Eve themselves was no longer secure. Throughout the rest of the Bible, we're going to see the pattern of insecure attachment. we are going to see that God consistently shows up as faithfully willing to restore securely attached relationship and humanity wrestling with whether or not they want to do that. this is where we're going to circle back to was it foolish for Eve to think that she could be God? When we choose not to enter into a securely attached relationship with God, it's because on some fundamental level, we are choosing to be our own God and securely attached not to someone else, but to ourselves. I'm gonna securely attach to me. I'm gonna trust me and no one else. Unfortunately, that's not how attachment works. The fundamental concept of attachment is one thing and another thing connecting. You can't have a fulfilled Relational experience in the full complexity of what your brain was designed for with just yourself. If you've ever watched the survival series alone, you will see that these people who go to live out in the wilderness based on their own strength and resources, they can be very successful at staying alive. But they can't live a full life. Because they don't have relationship, because they're not relationally attached to anyone. even when their physical needs are met in crazy circumstances, it is the attachments, the invisible attachments to people back home that pull them out of their self-deity and back into relationship. For the sake of our conversations, I'm going to frame Genesis 3 as the moment when relationship first ruptured. When we first experienced insecure attachment. that insecure attachment came because Adam and Eve decided on some level they wanted to be their own God. There's a lot more to unpack here, which we're gonna do in the next couple of conversations. for now I want you to consider. What would it mean to read the Bible as a story of attachment? Of God pursuing his people to restore a secure attachment? And how does that redefine how we experience emotion in Scripture? That's a big question, and we're gonna talk more about it. Start stirring up questions. I look forward to unpacking those with you in our future conversations.

Psychology and Scripture

Is it a sin to feel angry or afraid? Pull up a chair. Psychology and Scripture is a short, friendly Christian podcast about emotions, mental health, and therapy, where real psychology meets real Scripture.I'm Kia Gutiérrez, a Christian therapist: a licensed marriage and family therapist with over fifteen years of experience, and a floundering faith walker-outer. As a therapist, I believe there is a way of feeling our emotions that leads us to the healthiest choices we can make. How we do that is the part we should unpack.Each episode is short: a nugget of Christian psychology, a look at what the Bible says, and one thing to chew on this week. Not more to do, just more awareness of who God made you to be, and the confidence to do the next right thing.Our first series follows my book Emotions as Messengers. Start at the beginning or jump in wherever your question is.This podcast is for education and encouragement and is not a substitute for therapy or professional mental health care.Looking for conversations about the American church? Check out my first podcast, The Church We Dream Of.

  • Episodes
  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • About
  • Store
  • © 2026 Psychology and Scripture
  • Podcast Website by Podpage