Psychology and Scripture
  • Home
  • Episodes
    Christianity 1 Religion & Spirituality 1 Mental Health 1 Season 1 3 All Episodes 8
  • Leave a Review
  • About
  • Follow
    Spotify podcast player icon Spotify
    Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music
    All Players
  • Store
  • Search
Contact
Contact
Search
Oct. 7, 2026

Is the Bible a Rulebook or a Love Letter? - Psychology & Scripture

Is the Bible a Rulebook or a Love Letter? - Psychology & Scripture
Is the Bible a Rulebook or a Love Letter? - Psychology & Scripture
Psychology and Scripture
Is the Bible a Rulebook or a Love Letter? - Psychology & Scripture
Your browser does not support the audio tag.
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Season 1 Christianity Religion & Spirituality Mental Health
  • Show Notes
  • Transcript

Is the Bible a rulebook, a love letter, or something else? How you answer shapes what you do with your emotions.

Episode summary

Why does the Bible sometimes feel contradictory, uncomfortable, or hard to apply, especially when it comes to your feelings? In this episode, licensed marriage and family therapist Kia Gutiérrez explores how to read Scripture, the Old and New Testament, in light of what its authors were trying to communicate.

Kia explains how the lens we bring to the Bible, whether a rulebook to follow or a love letter written to us, shapes the answers we find and what we decide to do with our emotions. She proposes reading the Bible as a written document from an ancient community, shaped by its cultural context and inspired by the Holy Spirit, using Genesis 1 as an example of asking what the author was actually saying.

She also draws a parallel between Scripture and emotions: both are tools with a specific purpose, and just as a hammer makes a poor saw, using either one in a way it wasn't designed for leads to struggle and disappointment. Along the way, you'll hear how relearning both can bring peace to the places that feel contradictory, and how to sort which emotions to act on and which to sit with, and which Scripture guides your life directly and which shapes the way you see the world.

You'll finish with a question to carry into your week: how does it feel to relearn how to read the Bible and how to feel your emotions?

Kia Gutiérrez: Okay, I promised that we were gonna talk about emotions and scripture. We just talked a little bit about emotions. We just opened that can of worms. Now let's talk about scripture. Scripture is really important to navigating our emotions. But before we can do that, we need to understand what scripture is. When I say scripture, when I say let's talk about scripture, I mean the Holy Bible. I mean the Old Testament and the New Testament. The thing is, largely today, the average Bible reader in my life, and myself included, doesn't really understand what the Old and New Testament are. Like we understand that it is a book. Written to teach us about God and Jesus and that kind of stuff. But but how do we read it and why? why are there so many arguments about it and all of that stuff? there's a lot of different things that we can talk about that. the thing I want to highlight for our conversation is that when I talk about scripture, I'm gonna be talking about reading it the way that the author intended it to be read. if we approach the Bible. As a list of rules that we need to follow, literally, you're gonna get a very specific set of instructions on what to do with your life and how to feel your emotions. If you approach the Bible as a sort of love letter written directly to you, and you're kind of the you're the center of that universe, you're going to get a totally different set of experiences And ideas on what you should do with your emotion and what not to. depending on which way you lean on how to read the Bible, you're gonna be drawn to different sections of scripture and you're gonna be looking for different answers. Notice here that the way we interpret scripture is largely motivated by what we want to get out of it. What do we want to see? What do we want to learn? What is our current need? And how does it need to be fixed? I want to propose that the Bible is a written document. just like all written documents, the author of that document has a very specific message that it wants to send. it chose a particular writing style and format and language and word choice and final draft organization because it wants to communicate a specific message. If we want to understand what the Bible is saying, we need to read it with the intention of understanding what the author has to say. If we want to understand ourselves and our emotions, we need to understand their mission and what they are trying to say instead of imputing upon them our own interpretation, bias, or goal. Emotions are not something you picked up at the grocery store and said, you know what, I'd like that. I'll take that. I'm gonna have that and I'm gonna use it to do X, Y, and Z. The same is true of scripture. Scripture is not something that you picked up along the way and get to decide how to use it. It's a specific tool with a specific task, and there are specific ways that it will work. If you try and use a hammer as a saw, you're gonna struggle. If we try to use our emotions in a way that they weren't created to be used, we're gonna struggle. If we try and read scripture and look for things in the text that were never intended to be there, we're gonna be disappointed. So, in order to go on this journey well, in order for you and me to do this, in order for you to unlock the secrets of the universe. I'm selling a lot from my kitchen. I get that. you're gonna need permission to come in with a fresh blank slate. I'm gonna summarize a little bit of what I'm talking about with. The biblical author's intention. The Bible is not a little book of rules and it's also not a love letter. It is also not a scientific documentation of the creation of the world or a literal history book. It there's a lot of history in it. It is a book that covers the cosmology of the universe from the perspective of a minority ancient group of people. Another way to say that is the Bible is a book that is attempting to make meaning of life within the cultural context of the author's community inspired by the Holy Spirit. Genesis is an incredible example of this. When you read Genesis 1, are you reading it to scientifically understand how the world was created? Or are you reading it to understand the worldview of a minority group of people who is using the language and cultural resources and storytelling mechanisms that they have at that present time? to communicate to you their experience of something that they're calling God. How are feeling? We get so comfortable. We get so complacent with the magnitude of what is being communicated in scripture. We feel like we have it figured out. We think we have it figured out. Just like we think we have emotions figured out. Whether you're intentionally choosing a process for emotions or just pushing them aside, you have a process and you genuinely believe it works and you make Major life decisions based on that belief system. the same is true of scripture. You have a belief system around what scripture is. you know what's good and bad about that is good. You're willing to make big choices. You're willing to be influenced by this being called God that we learn about through a book that we call the Bible. The downside is if We are mishandling those resources. We're going to inevitably run into some really big questions and challenges. We're going to run into what feel like contradictions. Why am I uncomfortable with this part of scripture? Why does it feel like it challenges other morally significant parts of scripture? Why do my emotions feel inappropriate for the context of this situation? Why am I uncomfortable being in my own body? Why am I uncomfortable being in my own faith? A lot of people are very uncomfortable reading the Old Testament because they don't know how and it brings up a lot of themes that are difficult to process and digest. However, if we take the time and we're willing to relearn our bodies and our interpretation of Scripture, I truly believe that those places where you feel uncomfortable or where you feel like there's contradiction are going to come to peace. They are going to be resolved. You're going to be able to step forward and say, I am confident about what I read in scripture and how I want to apply it to my life in conjunction with my confidence of knowing what God is speaking to me, using emotions as part of that process. I can confidently step forward into this next step. It's gonna be a messy step for sure. You're not necessarily gonna know what happens after you take that step, but you're going to have the confidence. And there won't be the contradiction. You'll be like, I know exactly what that contradiction is, and I can logically work it out. I'm okay with feeling whatever I feel about it. I can sort between which emotions I need to act on and which emotions I need to sit with, which scripture should literally guide my life, and which scripture should inform my cosmology and therefore impact my life. There is just so much beauty to be explored. So How do you feel? How do you feel about reframing, relearning how to read the Bible and how to feel your emotions?

Psychology and Scripture

Is it a sin to feel angry or afraid? Pull up a chair. Psychology and Scripture is a short, friendly Christian podcast about emotions, mental health, and therapy, where real psychology meets real Scripture.I'm Kia Gutiérrez, a Christian therapist: a licensed marriage and family therapist with over fifteen years of experience, and a floundering faith walker-outer. As a therapist, I believe there is a way of feeling our emotions that leads us to the healthiest choices we can make. How we do that is the part we should unpack.Each episode is short: a nugget of Christian psychology, a look at what the Bible says, and one thing to chew on this week. Not more to do, just more awareness of who God made you to be, and the confidence to do the next right thing.Our first series follows my book Emotions as Messengers. Start at the beginning or jump in wherever your question is.This podcast is for education and encouragement and is not a substitute for therapy or professional mental health care.Looking for conversations about the American church? Check out my first podcast, The Church We Dream Of.

  • Episodes
  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • About
  • Store
  • © 2026 Psychology and Scripture
  • Podcast Website by Podpage