Psychology and Scripture
  • Home
  • Episodes
    Christianity 1 Religion & Spirituality 1 Mental Health 1 Season 1 3 All Episodes 8
  • Leave a Review
  • About
  • Follow
    Spotify podcast player icon Spotify
    Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music
    All Players
  • Store
  • Search
Contact
Contact
Search
Nov. 18, 2026

Can You Be Honest With God About Your Doubts? - Psychology & Scripture

Can You Be Honest With God About Your Doubts? - Psychology & Scripture
Can You Be Honest With God About Your Doubts? - Psychology & Scripture
Psychology and Scripture
Can You Be Honest With God About Your Doubts? - Psychology & Scripture
Your browser does not support the audio tag.
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
  • Show Notes
  • Transcript

Why did God tell Abraham to count the stars? A Christian therapist reads Genesis 15 through attachment, trauma, and emotional regulation.

Episode summary

What do you do when God has made you a promise and years go by without it coming true? In this episode, licensed marriage and family therapist Kia Gutiérrez walks through Genesis 15, where Abraham tells God he has no son, and shows what the passage reveals about trust, trauma, and how God responds when we’re honest about our doubts.

Kia argues that when we wrestle with whether a promise from God will come to pass, we’re usually asking something deeper: “Am I really loved by you?” She points out that God is the one who starts the conversation, that Abraham is completely honest about how he feels, and that God answers by confirming the promise and renewing their connection instead of brushing the struggle aside.

Then comes the part Kia loves most. When God tells Abraham to go outside and count the stars, she explains, he’s leading him through something research now shows is deeply regulating for the body: fresh air, a slower pace, and time to move through frustration toward remembering God’s faithfulness. She isn’t claiming the author of Genesis meant it that way, only that God created Abraham’s body and led him through a process that honored it. Kia compares this to how a parent soothes a crying baby, a picture of co-regulation with God. She credits Marty Solomon of the BEMA Podcast for first drawing her attention to this insight.

You’ll finish with a question to carry with you: is there a place in your life where God is starting a conversation, and what might happen if you let yourself feel those emotions in His presence?

Kia Gutiérrez: We were just talking about developmental trauma in the context of scripture, and I introduced the idea that developmental trauma is what happens when as we're growing we don't have a secure attachment. To our caregivers, or that our basic needs aren't being met as we grow. These can be emotional needs, social needs, physical needs, intellectual needs. All of these can result in different categories or manifestations of developmental trauma. Developmental trauma says: when I needed help, it wasn't there, so I need to adapt and function differently than I would. Inside of a secure relationship. It fundamentally says, I'm going to be independent and do this a little bit more by myself, if not completely by myself, than I would have, if I had relationships with people that I could trust. then we applied that concept to God, tying it back to Adam and Eve, and how in that initial rupture when they ate from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. That was the beginning of their developmental trauma with God. They inserted themselves into the situation and started to believe that God wasn't going to be there for them the way that they needed him to be. that pattern continues throughout scripture. at the end, I asked you to consider how does reading scripture change if we look at it through this lens and specifically how does it apply to our emotions. today I want to walk you through one of my favorite examples of this that I feel like highlights in a small space what Trauma can look like in a relationship between a human and God and how God responds to that trauma. we're gonna be in Genesis 15, and this is the Lord's covenant promise to Abraham, and I'm gonna be reading out of the New Living Translation. Genesis 15:1 says, Sometime later the Lord spoke to Abraham in a vision and said to him, Do not be afraid, Abraham, for I will protect you. And your reward will be great. But Abraham replied, O sovereign Lord, what good are all your blessings when I don't even have a son? Since you've given me no children, Elesiar of Damascus, a servant in my household, will inherit all my wealth. You haven't given me no descendants of my own, so one of my servants will be my heir. Then the Lord said to him, No, your servant will not be your heir, for you will have a son of your own who will be your heir. Then the Lord took Abraham outside and said to him, Look up into the sky and count the stars if you can. That's how many descendants you will have. And Abraham believed the Lord, and the Lord counted him as righteous because of his faith. In the context of the bigger story of Abraham's life, he made a choice early on when he chose his wife and To take the risk that he might not have children. But he did it because he believed in God. He believed in his secure attachment to God. As the years go on, he starts to question that attachment because his need is not being met over and over again. In order for this promise to come to pass, he's going to need to have a son. If someone keeps telling you that they're gonna provide something that you desperately need and then not providing that thing, if this is a human relationship, we're going to lose trust in that person eventually. Over time, we're not going to open ourselves up to them as much. We're not going to continue that relationship in some cases. this is not the first time that Abraham has come to God and said, I am not sure I can trust you. Trauma is threatening to enter the relationship. Abraham is wrestling with, can I really trust God? Am I really connected to him? Am I really loved by him? Is the question. Because whenever we have a promise from God and we're wrestling with whether or not it's going to come to pass. It's never really about whether or not the promise is going to happen or not. It is always down at the bedrock about whether or not we are loved by God. Abraham's talking about his son because he's talking about the fact that God promised him something, promised him something that Abraham has invested in and trusted God for. But more than anything, receiving this thing is going to make Abraham feel connected to God. It's going to make him feel loved. Regardless of whether or not Abraham actually gets a son, he can feel loved by God. And that's what happens in this passage. How does God respond to Abraham wrestling with the state of their attachment? Abraham wrestling with the question, but God, do you love me? Do you really love me? First, God is the one who instigates the conversation. He doesn't ignore Abraham's wrestle. He doesn't just brush it under the rug and say, hey, I'm God, I promised you something, therefore you should just trust me and not have any feelings about it. You should not have a journey in that process. I said it, my word doesn't come back void, period. I don't want to talk about it anymore. I just want you to believe. No. And it's not Abraham who comes and starts this conversation saying, hey, God, you're not enough. You're You're not answering like, I hoped you would. God instigates the conversation and says to Abraham, Remember, I have promised to protect you and your reward will be great. Then Abraham is incredibly honest about how he feels. He doesn't protect God from his wrestle. He's like, I don't have a son. I don't know what you're talking about. This isn't gonna work. You haven't given me any descendants. then God confirms in Genesis 15, 4, I promise you will have a son that is from your bloodline. I'm going to keep my word. You are securely attached to me. I do love you. And this next verse is my favorite part, Genesis 15, 5. Then the Lord took Abraham outside and said to him, Look up into the sky and count the stars if you can. That's how many descendants you will have. And Marty Solomon of the Bay Maw Podcast was the one who first drew my attention to the bigger narrative that's happening in that small verse in terms of psychology and regulation. We haven't talked a lot about regulation, but We have talked about the fact that emotions are chemical processes in our bodies that are involuntary and can't be ignored. And how we process them is important. So when God takes Abraham and says, look up into the sky and count the stars, if you were a child therapist or a therapist at all, or just a friend who was talking to someone who was stressed and they were having a really intense struggle and they were getting really activated, they're having a lot of difficult feelings about where they are in life to the point that they're getting dysregulated and unable to see logic, unable to see clearly. If you encourage them to go outside and count the stars, you're encouraging them to do something that's scientifically very regulating for their body. To go outside and breathe fresh air, very regulating. To slow the body down enough to count stars. Is psychologically and biologically very regulating. Do I think the original author who wrote Genesis 15:5 was like, I want to make sure everybody knows that God was regulating Abraham's body? No, that's not what I'm saying. But God created Abraham's body and led him through a process that we know now through research would be incredibly regulating. because these verses happen so close together. It's difficult to imagine how long Abraham was out there counting the stars. It just says that's how many descendants you will have, exclamation point. And Abraham believed the Lord. It feels very immediate, but if you're thinking about it in the context of a real human experience, Abraham probably spent a good amount of time sitting out there looking at the stars. Attempting to count them. I can see him being frustrated and counting them really fast he's I'll count them all, God. I'm gonna count them. I'm gonna prove to you that you can't be trusted because I am capable. Back to the original sin of the garden. I can do it myself. I can produce my own knowledge. Abraham attempts to count the stars and produce his own knowledge to be his own God, to be his own form of attachment, so that he can. Prove that he doesn't need to be with God because there's a rupture in that trust. God does not withdraw from that, but instead leads Abraham into an experience where he gets to process all of that emotion. as he's counting the stars, as he's getting more and more frustrated, as the numbers are getting bigger and bigger, he's going to start to have the bodily experience of realizing that counting the stars by himself by looking up with his eyes and pointing with his fingers. Is an impossible task. Because it's an impossible task, he starts to meditate on who created the stars, how many stars there are, and the goodness of God. He probably starts to remember all the things that God has done for him already that are impossible. He starts to remember his attachment to God and that it is secure and that God has been faithful to him. that regulates his nervous system. He gets the answer to his question Am I loved by God? As he moves through the emotions of anger, frustration, rejection, And then moves through a self-regulation process or a co-regulation process with God. When God reaches out and reestablishes that secure attachment, much like a mother to a child that's crying, the crying child, the crying baby is asking, Am I safe? Am I loved? The apparent reaches out and cradles and holds and rocks and leads that baby through a bodily regulation process. This is what God offers Abraham. then it says in Genesis fifteen six, and Abraham believed the Lord, and the Lord counted him as righteous because of his faith. It's not that Abraham denied himself and followed a ruthless, rigid God. It's that God drew near to a man who was created for connection with him and was wrestling with the question of. Am I really loved by you, God? Am I really securely attached? And walked him through a process that honored his body, his mind, and his spirit to confirm and teach him that the answer is yes, you are loved. Today I want you to consider, is there a place in your life where God is starting a conversation with you? That if you answer, it will bring up some uncomfortable emotions that you feel are not appropriate in the context of your relationship with God, or you're scared to bring them to Him because that attachment doesn't feel secure. what might happen if you allow yourself to feel those emotions in the presence of a God that you imagine to be very interested in allowing you to be the human. That he created you to be and go through the processes of feeling and relationship the way that he biologically created you to do that.

Psychology and Scripture

Is it a sin to feel angry or afraid? Pull up a chair. Psychology and Scripture is a short, friendly Christian podcast about emotions, mental health, and therapy, where real psychology meets real Scripture.I'm Kia Gutiérrez, a Christian therapist: a licensed marriage and family therapist with over fifteen years of experience, and a floundering faith walker-outer. As a therapist, I believe there is a way of feeling our emotions that leads us to the healthiest choices we can make. How we do that is the part we should unpack.Each episode is short: a nugget of Christian psychology, a look at what the Bible says, and one thing to chew on this week. Not more to do, just more awareness of who God made you to be, and the confidence to do the next right thing.Our first series follows my book Emotions as Messengers. Start at the beginning or jump in wherever your question is.This podcast is for education and encouragement and is not a substitute for therapy or professional mental health care.Looking for conversations about the American church? Check out my first podcast, The Church We Dream Of.

  • Episodes
  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • About
  • Store
  • © 2026 Psychology and Scripture
  • Podcast Website by Podpage