Psychology and Scripture
  • Home
  • Episodes
    Christianity 1 Religion & Spirituality 1 Mental Health 1 Season 1 3 All Episodes 8
  • Leave a Review
  • About
  • Follow
    Spotify podcast player icon Spotify
    Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music
    All Players
  • Store
  • Search
Contact
Contact
Search
Oct. 28, 2026

Are Emotions Right or Wrong?- Psychology & Scripture

Are Emotions Right or Wrong?- Psychology & Scripture
Are Emotions Right or Wrong?- Psychology & Scripture
Psychology and Scripture
Are Emotions Right or Wrong?- Psychology & Scripture
Your browser does not support the audio tag.
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music
More
  • Show Notes
  • Transcript

Are some emotions good and others bad? A Christian therapist explains why emotions are morally neutral, and what Jesus' emotions teach us.

Episode summary

Is it a sin to feel angry, sad, or afraid? Many Christians grew up sorting emotions into good ones and bad ones, and even the therapy world often talks about "positive" and "negative" emotions. In this episode, licensed marriage and family therapist Kia Gutiérrez explains why she believes emotions themselves carry no morality. Only our reactions to them do.

Because emotions are an involuntary chemical process in the body, Kia compares them to hunger and the need for sleep: you don't choose them, and you can't live without processing them. Even if you say you're "not an emotional person," your emotions are still there, just suppressed or blocked somewhere in your body. She also looks at how the word "should" (like "I should feel happy at this birthday party") sneaks moral judgment into our feelings, and why unexpected emotions are best treated as information that more is going on than you've considered.

Then Kia turns to Scripture. The Gospel writers portray Jesus with the full range of human emotion, including joy, frustration, grief, and sadness, and Scripture says he never sinned. If Jesus felt sad, why would we shame ourselves for feeling it? Kia explores what it means that Jesus didn't rush through hard emotions, and why she sees real value in them.

You'll finish with a question to consider: what changes in your life as a follower of Jesus if emotions themselves are morally neutral?

Kia Gutiérrez: We've been unpacking emotion and scripture, how they go together, and talking about reframing how we read scripture and how we understand emotion. Because we have inherited ways of reading scripture and ways of processing our emotions that significantly impact the choices that we make based on how we feel and how we read scripture. Today I want to talk about one of the things that we have inherited about emotion. And that is that emotion has been assigned morality. In other words, that language that says good emotions or bad emotions. I'm feeling angry is a bad emotion. I'm feeling happy is a good emotion. this is something that I wrestled with. in my study for marriage and family counseling, even in the therapy world, the language that we use around emotion does have a moral connotation to it. We do say, are you feeling a negative emotion? Are you feeling a positive emotion? it implies that one is bad and one is good, one is negative and one is positive. I wrestled with this because emotion in general doesn't have morality. Only our reaction to it has morality. Emotion itself is neutral. If you're sad, that's fine. It is neither good or bad to be sad. It just is. Because we talked about how emotions are a chemical process in our bodies. therefore, it can't have a moral weight. It's an involuntary response to be sad. You don't decide to be sad. It's something that happens in your body as a chemical reaction to your experience of the world. Saying that. Emotions have morality is like saying that hunger or the desire for sleep has morality. being hungry is an involuntary body response. The desire for sleep is necessary for survival, and in the same way, experiencing your emotions is just as essential of a chemical. And fundamental process in your body as eating and sleeping, it's not optional. one of the ways that we process our emotions is In our sleeping state, sometimes we have dreams and we go into a REM cycle. there has been studies that if you don't get to sleep, you can't live. You can't live long without sleep. You can't live without processing your emotions. And you might say, Well, I'm not an emotional person. That's like saying, I don't eat. You do that, you you may not have a healthy diet, you may not eat very much, but you are processing your emotions. Period. You have the full spectrum of emotions. They're somewhere in your body. If you're like, I never feel angry. That just means your anger is very suppressed somewhere, but it's still in your body. You could say, I never feel joy. You have joy. It's in your body somewhere, but it might be blocked or suppressed by something. It sounds like a simple concept to say that emotions are morally neutral, but when we apply it to living, it gets complicated. For example, you may have a birthday party where you should feel joyful. The should implies a moral right or wrong. The I should feel happy at this birthday party. Should implies that there's a correct response. predetermined for you by something else or someone else. But let's say you get to this birthday party and you're actually sad. How often have you been in a situation where it should be happy, but you feel sad? Does that mean that you're wrong? it's very common to feel uncomfortable with the fact that our emotions don't align with what they should be, what we assume would be correct in the moment. And that's what's finicky about emotion, is it it doesn't care. It doesn't care what you think should happen, it is going to be extreme in telling you exactly where you're at based on a complicated infrastructure of lived experience and belief systems that you have that you've inherited and basic survival things. Like there's a whole bunch going on in your body sending a chemical reaction of an emotion. But if Emotions have morality and you're at this birthday party and you feel sad, you're doing something wrong. You're wrong. In reality, it's neutral. You're at the birthday party and you're sad. It's not good or bad. It's neutral. It's neutral. You can be sad at the birthday party. That's okay. It's your birthday. You can cry if you want to. Maybe it's not your birthday. You can't cry. I don't know. How we react to being sad at the birthday party is the make or break of morality, if you will, which is a complicated conversation. But if we jump straight into decision making, assuming that because you're sad at a birthday party, you're wrong, you're gonna make a different set of decisions. You're gonna do something to make that sadness go away. We don't know. Maybe the birthday party is sad and that should be acknowledged. Maybe it's the birthday party and someone you really love isn't there. Okay. Now you're like, well, you've given me different information. So now it seems fine to be sad at a birthday party. That's all emotions are is information. if the information that you're receiving through your body, through emotion, is different than what you think it should be, that just means. That there's more happening in that situation than you have considered. And how beautiful is that? That there is a more layered human experience. There's a more layered conversation happening between you and God Then you've currently opened yourself up to. That can be overwhelming. It can be exciting. You're going to have a different emotional reaction to that. based on your life, your experiences. Now I've said a lot of psychology things, but I want to back this up with one of my favorite people in the Bible who I think models pretty well what this can look like in practice. That's Jesus. Jesus feels all of his emotions in the Bible. it says in scripture that he never sinned. Please put a pin in the word sin because we're going to come back to that and talk more about what is sin. Because that's a loaded word that we have a lot of feelings and experiences and scriptural data for. for now. Whatever sin is considered morally not good, less than ideal, and Jesus didn't do it. it's very important to our theology of Christianity that Jesus didn't do whatever sin is, however you define it. And he felt all of his emotions. The story of Jesus' life is accounted for in the Gospels, who were written from the perspective of multiple people who chose in all of their accounts to portray Jesus as a human with emotion, who was frustrated, who was joyful, who was sad, They decided to portray Jesus with the full spectrum of emotion, celebration and joy, grief and sadness. We also get to see how he reacted to those emotions, which we'll talk about later, but that's jumping way ahead. We need to start with: if Jesus felt all emotion, why would we ever shame ourselves for feeling an emotion? Why would we ever assign morality? To emotion because if we're doing that, if we're saying that half of the emotions are quote bad, then Jesus did a quote bad thing by feeling sad. I'm breaking it down so small because I want you to see this tiny crack in our foundation has incredible ramifications through our personal lives, our relationships. And our communities. I'm sure you can extrapolate what some of those are. But if we go back down to the simplicity of it, is if Jesus felt sad, you can feel sad. he didn't rush through his emotions either. He didn't go like, I'm sad. that's bad. Better get away from it. Better rush through that. He went to, I'm pretty sure it was three funerals in his three years of ministry and only one wedding. Jesus is a fan of what we call the negative or bad emotions, sadness, fear, grief, anger. He is very clearly represented, not only experiencing those things, but encouraging his disciples to feel them with him and rerouting his ministry path in order to engage more deeply with those emotions, with those experiences. There is value in them, and They are not sin. I want you to take a minute and consider the concept that emotions themselves are morally neutral and start to consider what are the implications for that reality in your life as a follower of Jesus who allowed himself to experience the full emotional spectrum.

Psychology and Scripture

Is it a sin to feel angry or afraid? Pull up a chair. Psychology and Scripture is a short, friendly Christian podcast about emotions, mental health, and therapy, where real psychology meets real Scripture.I'm Kia Gutiérrez, a Christian therapist: a licensed marriage and family therapist with over fifteen years of experience, and a floundering faith walker-outer. As a therapist, I believe there is a way of feeling our emotions that leads us to the healthiest choices we can make. How we do that is the part we should unpack.Each episode is short: a nugget of Christian psychology, a look at what the Bible says, and one thing to chew on this week. Not more to do, just more awareness of who God made you to be, and the confidence to do the next right thing.Our first series follows my book Emotions as Messengers. Start at the beginning or jump in wherever your question is.This podcast is for education and encouragement and is not a substitute for therapy or professional mental health care.Looking for conversations about the American church? Check out my first podcast, The Church We Dream Of.

  • Episodes
  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • About
  • Store
  • © 2026 Psychology and Scripture
  • Podcast Website by Podpage